Why is it so hard to speak up for myself? People pleasing, fawning and the weight of being dismissed
If you only have a minute: saying yes when you mean no, over-explaining and going quiet are often ways we learned to stay safe. They make sense. And past experiences of being dismissed can make speaking up cost more energy than people realise. You don’t need to change everything at once. One clear ask is enough to begin.
Have you ever said yes before you’d even thought about it? Or explained yourself three times over, just in case? Or gone quiet in a conversation, then replayed it for days afterwards, working out what you wish you’d said?
You might recognise that. Or you might recognise it in someone you love.
Speaking up for ourselves sounds simple. Share what you need, ask for help, set a boundary. But for many of us, it’s one of the hardest things to do, especially when we’ve learned, sometimes over many years, that our needs cause trouble or won’t be taken seriously.
This post is part of our How I’m Wired series. It looks at why speaking up can feel so hard, the different ways we try to keep the peace, and what can make it a little easier.
Why do I say yes when I want to say no?
People pleasing might mean saying yes when you want to say no, keeping your preferences to yourself, or feeling responsible for keeping everybody happy.
We can choose to help someone and want to do it. That isn’t the problem. The question is whether there’s room for our own needs and choices as well.
There may be real pressures behind a yes. A parent agrees to one more thing because saying no could upset several people. A colleague takes on extra work because their job feels insecure. Those pressures matter too, so let’s understand them rather than simply call it “people pleasing”.
Over time, though, a lot of yeses can leave someone stretched, resentful, or unsure how to ask for help at all.
What is the fawn response?
You may have heard people pleasing described as “fawning”. Psychotherapist Pete Walker named the fawn response in his book Complex PTSD: From Surviving to Thriving (2013). He added it to the more familiar fight, flight and freeze. In his description, fawning means responding to a threat by becoming more agreeable to it: keeping the other person happy so things stay safe.
It’s a useful idea, and many people say it helped them make sense of themselves for the first time. It’s worth knowing what it is and isn’t, though. The fawn response is not a diagnosis. Most of what we know about it comes from clinical experience and people’s own accounts, rather than controlled research.
Researchers have described related patterns too:
- Tend and befriend. In 2000, psychologist Shelley Taylor and colleagues suggested that under stress, people often protect those close to them and reach out for support. They found this more marked in women, though men do it too. This isn’t about trauma. It’s one of the ordinary ways humans cope together.
- Appeasement. In 2023, Rebecca Bailey, Jaycee Dugard, Stephen Porges and colleagues proposed replacing the term “Stockholm syndrome” with “appeasement”. They describe it as a survival strategy: calming a person who holds power over you, to reduce harm. Their account draws on polyvagal theory, which is itself debated, and other researchers have questioned where the idea came from. What it gets right is the dignity of it. Appeasing someone dangerous isn’t weakness or loyalty to them. It can be survival.
The different ways we keep the peace
Appeasing doesn’t always look like smiling and agreeing. In Glad We Talked®, we call these protection patterns: responses that can show up under pressure. They describe what we do in a moment, not who we are. Some you might recognise:
- Saying yes automatically, then feeling resentful or exhausted later.
- Going quiet. Freezing, holding things in and trying to keep the peace. For me, it often began this way, and from the outside it could look like I’d exploded out of nowhere when it finally spilled over.
- Over-explaining, so no one can misunderstand, blame or doubt you.
- Apologising first, even when you’re not sure anything was wrong.
- Doing it all yourself, because asking has felt risky or pointless before.
- Masking: changing how you speak, move or react so you fit in or feel safer.
That’s my pattern and a few common ones. You may experience something different, and that’s okay.
Is people pleasing a trauma response?
Sometimes, but not always.
For some people, keeping others happy started in childhood, when a grown-up’s mood decided whether home felt safe. For others, it grew from being corrected again and again for how they spoke, moved or felt. Many neurodivergent people describe learning that being themselves got a bad reaction, so they started to predict and prevent it. Some describe intense pain around rejection, which you may hear called rejection sensitive dysphoria, or RSD. We can take that feeling seriously while checking what the other person actually said and did.
Culture, gender, faith, family roles and power all shape it too. In some families and communities, putting others first is a value, not a symptom.
So we don’t need to label it to take it seriously. A more useful question might be: what is this pattern protecting me from, and what is it costing me now?
Why do I over-explain myself?
You might be thinking, “If I explain it properly, they’ll understand. They’ll know I’m not lying.”
Detail can be useful. Some people need it to understand or process information. But sometimes we keep explaining because we’re worried about being misunderstood, blamed or not believed. All those extra words can leave everyone more tired, while the thing we wanted understood still isn’t clearer.
A prompt I find helpful: “Am I adding information, or trying harder and harder to feel understood, believed or liked?”
How does being dismissed make it harder to speak up?
Think about a dripping tap. One drip, then another. You might barely notice it at first. But after a while, that repeated sound is hard to ignore.
Being dismissed builds up in the same way. A concern gets brushed off. You try to explain and come away feeling unheard. Over time, you might start expecting the next conversation to go the same way. Perhaps you stop asking, or rehearse something ordinary for days before saying it.
Research backs this up. One study in 2003 by Elizabeth Krause and colleagues found that adults who remembered their emotions being punished or played down as children were more likely to hold their feelings in, and that holding feelings in was linked to more anxiety and depression.
It doesn’t only happen in childhood. In a study of 1,248 autistic adults, a sense of not being believed by healthcare professionals ran through every stage of trying to get help. Many described doubting themselves before they’d even booked an appointment.
Those old messages can stay with us as an inner voice: “You’re too sensitive.” “Everyone else manages.” They can affect whether we pause, ask for an adjustment or ask for help at all. We can begin by noticing the message and asking what else is true.
And if someone doesn’t respond to your need, that isn’t, by itself, proof that your need was unreasonable or that you explained it badly.
Why do I wait until I’m falling apart to ask for help?
Because asking for help takes energy, and often the energy runs out first.
In Glad We Talked®, we use energy maths: comparing what a situation asks of us with what we have available to manage it, including energy, attention, time, recovery, resources and support. Speaking up is part of that sum. So is everything that came before it.
Here’s part of my own story. My Access to Work journey took around three and a half years. I was asked to send information within fourteen days, but finding documents, keeping track of what was needed and responding in time were exactly the things I found hard. The difficulties I needed support with were making it harder to get the support. On one call, I was asked to provide documents there and then, with no warning. The tone of voice brought up shame, and I shut down.
Being a therapist, or being able to teach about communication, doesn’t mean I can always find the words for myself in the moment. Wanting help, recognising what we need, explaining it, and completing the steps to receive it are different tasks. We may manage one and struggle with another.
That’s why good support includes how communication happens: more processing time, information in manageable stages, help keeping track of the next step, and a way of communicating that fits the person. Spoken words aren’t a condition for receiving support.
How do I ask for reasonable adjustments in the UK?
Under the Equality Act 2010, employers must make reasonable adjustments for disabled workers. The Act covers England, Wales and Scotland. Northern Ireland has a different law. A reasonable adjustment is a change that removes or reduces a disadvantage related to someone’s disability, like a different way of doing a task, flexible hours, or written instructions.
If your needs go beyond what an employer would usually provide, Access to Work may help. You apply yourself, on GOV.UK.
A few things that can make asking easier:
- Write it down first. One clear concern and one clear ask.
- Ask for what would have helped. For me, that would have been being told in advance which documents I’d need for the call.
- Choose the format. An email, a form or a written note can count as speaking up.
- Bring someone with you, if that helps.
This is general information, not legal advice. Acas and Citizens Advice can help with your situation.
Trying the three prompts on one moment
Throughout Glad We Talked®, we return to three prompts:
- What is actually happening?
- What might be contributing? In other words, what could be making this moment harder?
- What could help?
Let’s try them. Someone asks you to take on one more thing, and you hear yourself say yes.
- What is actually happening? I said yes, and my chest went tight.
- What might be contributing? I’m already tired. Their tone reminded me of being told off. Saying no has gone badly before.
- What could help? Next time, “Can I get back to you this afternoon?” That gives me a pause before I decide.
You don’t need to work through every prompt at once. Recognising one thing, even afterwards, is enough to begin. You can still be angry and express a clear boundary. And if you said yes and wish you hadn’t, you can go back and say so.
Then return to it. What changed, and what still needs support?
If speaking up could put you at risk, because someone is hurting or threatening you, your safety comes first. Keeping the peace may be what’s protecting you right now. Our crisis support page lists free UK helplines, and you can call Samaritans any time on 116 123.
How this connects to How I’m Wired
Speaking Up for Myself is one of 10 sections in How I’m Wired, our free strengths and needs reflection tool for adults. It looks at how you share your views, needs and wishes, including asking for help and setting boundaries. It isn’t a diagnosis, and there are no right or wrong answers.
Your answers might change over time, too. We look at why in Why can I cope one week and not the next?
If you’d like a gentler way in, or something to explore with a young person, our Neurosloth® trait cards include Freeze Response and Autonomy. We always suggest adults explore the cards for themselves first.
Try this section of How I’m Wired for free
Frequently asked questions
What is the fawn response?
The fawn response is a term from psychotherapist Pete Walker for keeping someone happy to stay safe, alongside fight, flight and freeze. It’s a helpful description, not a diagnosis, and research on it is still limited.
Is people pleasing a trauma response?
It can be, but not always. It can also grow from being repeatedly corrected or dismissed, from masking, from culture and family roles, or from real pressures in someone’s life.
Why do I over-explain myself?
Often because we’re worried about being misunderstood, blamed or not believed. Detail can help, but if the extra words aren’t making things clearer, it may be worth pausing.
Why is it so hard to ask for help?
Asking takes energy, and past experiences of being dismissed make it cost more. Wanting help, knowing what you need, explaining it and following the steps to get it are all separate tasks.
What are reasonable adjustments?
Changes an employer makes to remove or reduce a disadvantage related to someone’s disability. In England, Wales and Scotland, the Equality Act 2010 says employers must make them.
Sources
- Walker (2013), Complex PTSD: From Surviving to Thriving, via Psychology Today
- Fawn response: limits of the evidence
- Taylor et al. (2000), Tend-and-Befriend, Not Fight-or-Flight, Psychological Review
- Bailey, Dugard, Smith and Porges (2023), Appeasement: replacing Stockholm syndrome, European Journal of Psychotraumatology
- Schlote (2023), History of the term ’appeasement’: a response to Bailey et al.
- Krause, Mendelson and Lynch (2003), Childhood emotional invalidation and adult psychological distress, Child Abuse & Neglect00536-7>)
- Shaw et al. (2023), barriers to healthcare for autistic adults (BSMS summary)
- Acas: reasonable adjustments at work
- Scope: a manager’s guide to Access to Work
- Access to Work, GOV.UK
- Glad We Talked® Module 1 lessons 2.001, 2.002, 2.004, 5.000 and 6.003 (Yasmin’s own wording)
Related articles
- “I don’t know what I’m feeling”: emotions, the body and why we go from fine to overwhelmed
- Why can’t I just start? Planning, focus and executive function, without the shame
- What is masking? The hidden cost of fitting in, and why unmasking is a choice
- Why can I cope one week and not the next? Capacity, resilience and the different parts of us
About the author
Yasmin Shaheen-Zaffar: BACP Accredited Counsellor, Creative Health Innovator and founder of Glad We Talked®, Finding My Steady and Neurosloth® Academy.