Glad We Talked®

“I don’t know what I’m feeling”: emotions, the body and why we go from fine to overwhelmed

By ·

If you only have a minute: not knowing what you feel is common, and it isn’t coldness or avoidance. Feelings start as signals in the body, and some of us find those signals hard to notice, hard to read, or very intense. “How do you feel?” isn’t the only way in. Sometimes “what happened?” is easier.

Someone asks, “What’s wrong?” and you say, “Nothing.” Not because you’re hiding anything. You don’t know yet.

Or you’re fine, fine, fine, and then suddenly you’re not, and you can’t explain how you got there.

You might recognise that. Or you might find body signals difficult to notice at all. Either way, we begin with whatever you do notice.

This post is part of our How I’m Wired series. It looks at how we experience, understand and respond to emotions, and what helps when the words won’t come.

Why can’t I tell what I’m feeling?

There are lots of possible reasons, and most of them are ordinary.

You may be tired, uncertain, or still processing. The feeling may be several feelings at once. You may have learned, a long time ago, that showing feelings wasn’t safe or welcome. Or the signals from your body may be faint, confusing or overwhelming.

Sometimes our body responds before we can explain it. Shoulders tighten, a sigh escapes, our voice changes, and only later do we work out what it was about.

Thinking isn’t the same as communicating, either. There can be a lot happening inside, even when very little shows on the outside.

What is alexithymia?

Alexithymia is a word for difficulty identifying and describing emotions. It isn’t a diagnosis or a lack of feeling. People with alexithymia still have emotional depth and care about others.

It’s more common in some groups. A 2019 review by Emma Kinnaird and colleagues found about half of autistic people in the studies met the threshold for alexithymia, compared with about 1 in 20 non-autistic people. The authors’ conclusion matters: it’s common in autism, not universal.

A caution from our programme: not being able to answer “How do you feel?” in one moment doesn’t automatically mean someone has alexithymia.

What is interoception?

Interoception is noticing signals from inside the body, such as hunger, thirst, tiredness, or the changes that come with feelings.

People experience these signals differently. They may be difficult to notice, difficult to interpret, or very intense.

Researchers Rebecca Brewer, Richard Cook and Geoffrey Bird have suggested alexithymia may be part of a wider difference in interoception. In their study, people who found emotions hard to identify also tended to find other body signals harder to read, and harder to tell apart from emotions. Is this a racing heart because I’m anxious, excited, or just had coffee?

This is one view, and the science is still developing. But it explains why “Where do you feel it in your body?” won’t help everyone. For one person, it gives a starting point. For another, it adds a question they cannot answer.

Why do I go from fine to overwhelmed so fast?

Often it isn’t fast. The build-up just wasn’t visible, sometimes not even to you.

For me, it often began with going quiet. I’d hold things in and try to keep the peace. From the outside, it might have looked as though I’d exploded out of nowhere. Underneath, it had been bubbling and simmering until I couldn’t hold any more. I wasn’t always aware of that build-up myself. That was something I understood later.

That’s my pattern. You may experience something different.

Psychiatrist Dan Siegel calls the zone where we can feel and think at the same time the “window of tolerance”. I picture it as a Sandwich of Capacity™: stressors squeeze the middle thin, and supports widen it again. When the sandwich is already squashed by a hard day, one more question can tip us over. You can explore yours with the free Sandwich of Capacity™ Builder.

Understanding the build-up doesn’t make every reaction okay. It helps us recognise what was building, take responsibility, and work out what needs to change.

Why do I shut down?

When things feel too much, someone might become very quiet, stop responding, or pull away. Taking in information or communicating may become difficult.

Being unable to respond is different from choosing to take a break. From the outside, they can look similar. Quietness alone doesn’t tell us which is happening.

In Glad We Talked®, we call this a protection pattern: a response that can show up under pressure. It describes a moment, not a person.

Does naming feelings actually help?

For many people, yes, a little.

In a 2007 brain imaging study, psychologist Matthew Lieberman and colleagues found that putting a feeling into words was linked to a calmer response in the amygdala, a part of the brain involved in alarm. He compared it to pressing the brake when you see an amber light.

A few honest limits. These are small lab studies, mostly using pictures of faces. And if you can’t find the word in the first place, being told to “name it to tame it” can feel like one more thing you’re failing at. Naming is one way in. It isn’t the only one.

What helps when I can’t find the words?

We can offer different ways in:

  • Start with what happened, not how you feel. What happened? Which part became difficult? Is there something you want to change?
  • Use something other than words. Pictures, drawing or writing may help. Colour or weather might make sense: is it stormy, foggy, flat?
  • Try pleasant or unpleasant. You don’t need the exact word. “Something’s off” is information.
  • Give it time. “You don’t have to explain everything now. You can show me, write it down, or come back to me.”
  • Find an outlet. Talking with someone you trust, writing privately, scribbling, moving or making music can release some of what we’re holding, before we know what to do next.

You can also use our three prompts:

  1. What is actually happening?
  2. What might be contributing? In other words, what could be making this moment harder?
  3. What could help?

Recognising one thing, even afterwards, is enough to begin.

If your feelings are frightening, or you’re thinking about harming yourself, please reach out now. In the UK you can call Samaritans free on 116 123, any time. Our crisis support page lists more free helplines.

How this connects to How I’m Wired

My Emotions is one of 10 sections in How I’m Wired, our free strengths and needs reflection tool for adults. It looks at how you experience, understand and respond to emotions, and how you cope. It isn’t a diagnosis, and there are no right or wrong answers.

For more on why capacity shifts, see Why can I cope one week and not the next? Our Neurosloth® trait cards include Emotional Flooding, Feeling Flat and Over Thinking.

Try this section of How I’m Wired for free

Frequently asked questions

Why can’t I tell what I’m feeling?

Common reasons include tiredness, still processing, having learned to hide feelings, or body signals that are faint, confusing or very intense.

What is alexithymia?

Difficulty identifying and describing emotions. It isn’t a diagnosis or a lack of feeling. It’s common, though not universal, among autistic people.

What is interoception?

Noticing signals from inside the body, such as hunger, tiredness or a racing heart. People vary in how clearly they notice and read these signals.

Why do I go from fine to overwhelmed so quickly?

Usually there’s a build-up that wasn’t visible. When capacity is already low, a small extra demand can tip things over.

Does naming your feelings help?

Research suggests putting feelings into words can calm the brain’s alarm response a little. It’s one way in, and other ways, like drawing or describing what happened, count too.

Sources

Related articles

About the author

: BACP Accredited Counsellor, Creative Health Innovator and founder of Glad We Talked®, Finding My Steady and Neurosloth® Academy.

More articles